
I’ve been a trader and investor for 44 years. I left Wall Street long ago—-once I understood that their obsolete advice is designed to profit them, not you.
Today, my firm manages around $5 billion in ETFs, and I don’t answer to anybody. I tell the truth because trying to fool investors doesn’t help them, or me.
In Daily H.E.A.T. , I show you how to Hedge against disaster, find your Edge, exploit Asymmetric opportunities, and ride major Themes before Wall Street catches on.
Two trading desks see a shakier September. Here is how to lower a hedge’s upfront premium without pretending the risk is free.
At about 11:25 a.m. Eastern on Monday, the S&P 500 traded near 7,676, down about 0.5% from Friday’s 7,711.76 close.
The index remained about 1.6% below its record closing high of 7,798.99, set on August 13. It was about 1.8% below that day’s record intraday high of 7,816.70.
The Cboe Volatility Index, or VIX, traded near 15.2 and estimated the S&P 500’s expected volatility over the next 30 days.
The VIX was up from Friday’s 14.43 close but remained only about two points above its 52-week low of 13.38.
Low broad-market volatility and a shakier tape can create a useful hedging window, but they do not make every option cheap.
The sale level written into the contract, its expiration date, the extra charge for crash protection, and trading costs still determine any hedge’s price.
Monday’s decline also had an immediate cause: renewed U.S.-Iran clashes lifted oil prices and inflation concerns as Fed Chair Kevin Warsh’s hawkish message raised rate-hike expectations.
The trading-desk warnings did not cause that selloff. They matter because they describe why the market may be more fragile when new shocks arrive.
Scott Rubner, Head of Equity and Equity Derivatives Strategy at Citadel Securities, remains constructive on stocks over the longer term. A client note supplied to me describes a narrower concern about September.
Retail buying, corporate buybacks, and falling volatility helped carry the market through August, but Rubner argues that those tailwinds may fade after Labor Day.
He is not calling for a bear market; he sees a tactical air pocket and favors buying downside protection before September’s major options expiration.
JPMorgan Chase & Co. (NYSE: JPM) went further, moving its trading desk to a “tactically cautious” stance for the next two to three weeks.
The desk suggested reducing net-long exposure. It also mentioned dollar-neutral or market-neutral positioning, which uses offsetting long and short exposure so broad market direction matters less.
Four Verified Reasons for Caution
The public summary of JPMorgan’s call gave four reasons, none of which predicts a crash by itself.
Together, they argue for owning protection rather than guessing the exact size or date of a decline.
First, the Federal Reserve’s September meeting is live. Kevin Warsh is already Fed Chair, having taken office on May 22, 2026.
The Federal Open Market Committee meets September 15–16. After Warsh’s hawkish Jackson Hole speech, traders put the odds of a September rate increase above 60%.
A hike is no longer a remote surprise because the market has partly priced it, although those odds can move quickly with new data.
The consumer price index, the government’s main inflation measure, is due September 11 at 8:30 a.m. Eastern. That report could strengthen or weaken the case for a hike.
Second, investor positioning gives no clean signal. A crowded market can unwind violently when nearly everyone leans the same way.
JPMorgan says current positioning is not clearly bullish or bearish, removing one useful guide to the next move.
Third, corporate bond issuance usually increases after Labor Day. A large supply of new bonds can pressure credit spreads when investor demand fails to absorb it smoothly.
A credit spread is the extra yield investors demand over safer Treasury debt, and wider spreads can signal rising concern about corporate risk.
Heavy issuance does not automatically widen spreads. The result also depends on investor demand, dealers’ capacity to absorb bonds, and borrower quality.
Fourth, September has the market’s weakest long-term record. The S&P 500 has averaged a 1.16% September decline since 1926.
Seasonality is a historical average, not a law, and September can still rally as it did in 2024 and 2025.
Two More Tests Under the Surface
Momentum leadership is also under pressure. Momentum means buying stocks with the strongest recent price trends and expecting those trends to continue.
The iShares MSCI USA Momentum Factor ETF (Cboe BZX: MTUM) closed Friday at $299.71. That was 13.2% below its 52-week high of $345.47, although its net asset value remained up about 20% for the year.
Those public figures are not the same as JPMorgan’s proprietary momentum indexes. They show that former leaders have weakened without proving the private note’s exact 21% and 34% drawdowns.
Broadcom Inc. (Nasdaq: AVGO) reports earnings after the close on September 2. The important test is not only whether Broadcom beats estimates.
The larger question is whether good news lifts the semiconductor group. A strong report followed by a weak sector reaction would show that investors now demand more than another earnings beat.
That would not end the artificial-intelligence buildout. It would suggest that the easy phase of the trade has become harder.
Why Protection Looks Relatively Inexpensive
The VIX is not the price of one put option; it is a 30-day estimate built from many S&P 500 call and put prices.
At roughly 15.2, the VIX remains near the bottom of its 52-week range. Broad-index implied volatility is therefore low compared with recent stress periods.
Implied volatility is the amount of future movement embedded in an option’s price. Lower implied volatility can reduce the upfront premium for some index hedges.
The phrase “zero-cost hedge” needs care because it usually means zero initial net option premium, not zero economic cost or zero risk.
Trading spreads, commissions, collateral, taxes, lost upside, and a potential loss zone still matter, so every cheaper hedge gives something up.
The Hedging Toolkit
A hedge is a position designed to gain when another holding loses value. Here are four common structures, from simple to more advanced.
1. The protective put. A put gives its buyer the right to sell an asset at a set strike price by a set date.
A protective put places a floor under a stock or ETF position during the option’s life. The buyer’s maximum option loss is the premium paid.
The protection is not unlimited. A stock cannot fall below zero, and the put expires on a fixed date.
2. The bear put spread. Buy one put and sell a lower-strike put with the same expiration.
The lower-strike sale reduces the initial premium but also caps the hedge’s payoff once the market falls below that strike.
This structure works when you want protection against a defined decline rather than every possible disaster.
3. The ratio put backspread. Sell one higher-strike put and buy two lower-strike puts with the same expiration.
The structure can sometimes be opened for little net premium or a small credit, but that does not mean the position has little risk.
Its maximum loss usually occurs near the lower strike at expiration. That loss can be meaningful if the market declines moderately but stops before the extra long put takes over.
If the market falls below the lower break-even—the level where the trade starts profiting at expiration—the two long puts begin to dominate the one short put. The payoff then accelerates as the decline deepens.
That acceleration is called convexity. It is why the structure can work as protection against a sharp, low-probability market break.
Building the Hedge
For broad S&P 500 exposure, compare several structures using the same expiration date. Start with the protective put, then test a put spread and a ratio backspread.
The correct strikes depend on live option quotes, the protection period, and the maximum loss you will accept.
S&P 500 Index options, known by the symbol SPX, settle in cash and use European-style exercise. That means they generally cannot be exercised before expiration and do not deliver shares.
Stock and ETF options work differently because they normally deliver the underlying shares when exercised or assigned.
For AI and semiconductor exposure, another idea is to buy puts on something like The VanEck Semiconductor ETF (Nasdaq: SMH).
Position size matters as much as strike selection. Compare the call exposure and index hedge by dollar exposure and how strongly each option moves, not merely by contract count.
There are other more sophisticated strategies that are beyond the scope of this note.
What We Are Doing
We are not abandoning long-term exposure to U.S. equities or the AI buildout because of one cautious desk note. We are reducing the amount of that exposure left unprotected through the September 15–16 Fed meeting and September 18 options expiration.
We added hedges in $MEMY ( ▲ 1.48% ) yesterday.
I have often said that investing has a lot in common with poker and blackjack. You can never predict, but you can know when the odds are in your favor or not. In blackjack if the dealer is showing a 5 and you have 11, then you double down. You aren’t always going to win, but the odds of winning are in your favor. If you have a 15 and the dealer has a 10 then the odds of winning are not in your favor.
You don’t have to be a market genius to see when the odds of success aren’t in your favor. You don’t go to cash, but you do reduce your bets and/or your bet size.
I am not saying the market is going to go down and I am not raising cash. All I’m saying is that the risk/reward feels skewed towards the risk side right now.
What Changes My Mind
On the Fed. I get less cautious if the September 11 inflation report is soft and market-implied odds of a September hike fall below 25%.
I get more cautious if those odds rise above 75% after the report. The trigger is the market’s repricing, not one economist’s forecast.
On the broader market. I get less cautious if the S&P 500 closes above its 7,798.99 record close while the VIX closes below 14.43 for two sessions.
I get more cautious if the S&P 500 closes below 7,650 while the VIX closes above 20. That combination would show falling prices and rising demand for protection.
On the AI trade. I get more constructive if Broadcom and SMH both close higher on the first full session after Broadcom reports.
I get more cautious if Broadcom beats expectations but SMH still closes more than 2% lower. That would confirm that good news is losing power at the group level.
On timing. I will watch the week after September 18. If the S&P 500 stabilizes after options expire, positioning may have caused the turbulence.
If weakness continues while the VIX stays above 20, the problem is probably broader than an expiration-related reset.
Investment Implications
Low VIX levels make some broad-index hedges cheaper than during a panic, but they do not make every option cheap.
A protective put buys the cleanest floor but requires premium. A put spread reduces that premium by limiting the payoff.
The real decision is not whether protection is free. It is which cost you prefer: cash premium, capped upside, basis risk, or a loss zone.
The Bottom Line
A private Citadel Securities note and JPMorgan’s public desk call point toward a more fragile September without forecasting a crash.
The S&P 500 remains close to its record, while the VIX remains near the low end of its yearly range. That combination makes this a reasonable time to compare hedges before volatility becomes expensive.
Put spread, and ratio backspreads can all lower initial premium by replacing some premium cost with another form of risk.
The edge is not predicting the storm. It is choosing what you are willing to give up before the storm arrives.
News vs. Noise
Some of my market thoughts…..
The news. September opened with the bond market doing exactly what Warsh said markets should do: send a signal. The 10-year Treasury yield hit roughly 4.79%, its highest level since mid-January 2025, while Japan’s 10-year touched 3% for the first time since 1996. Brent is back above $91 after renewed U.S.-Iran violence around Hormuz. This is not a clean “rates up because growth is great” move. It is inflation, deficits, oil, AI debt, and term premium all in one trade. Warsh made the Fed’s side clear at Jackson Hole: 2% PCE is a “firm, fixed target,” short-term rates are the main tool, inflation is still too high, and broad financial conditions are not restrictive. Reuters says Barclays now expects hikes in September and December, and markets price about a 60% chance of a September move. The Fed is not giving September a free pass.
The noise. The noise is that Nvidia’s latest move is just another bullish AI partnership. It is bullish, but it is also strategic balance-sheet warfare. Nvidia is investing $3.5 billion in MediaTek convertible bonds and expanding the partnership across AI infrastructure, local AI computing, and automotive. MediaTek will use NVLink Fusion so customers can build custom XPUs that plug into Nvidia’s rack-scale AI factories. That matters because enterprises and hyperscalers are looking for cheaper models, model choice, Google TPUs, open-source options, and custom silicon. Nvidia is not pretending that world will not exist. It is trying to make sure the custom-chip world still connects through Nvidia. The company wants to own the toll road, not just sell the cars.
The dumb advice. The dumb advice is treating this as a binary market: either Warsh kills risk or Nvidia saves it. The real answer is more annoying. AI demand is real. Software is not dead. Nvidia’s ecosystem is getting stronger. But September’s setup is worse than August’s. Citadel’s September note says earnings are mostly behind us, retail demand usually fades, corporate buybacks start moving toward blackout, systematic exposure has already rebuilt, and downside protection is cheap. It also says roughly $9.6 trillion of U.S. options exposure expires between now and September 18. That is not a reason to panic. It is a reason not to chase. The best trades now separate real bottlenecks from momentum tourists.
Takeaways.
Warsh made September live. Friday’s jobs report matters.
The 10-year near 4.8% and Japan’s 10-year at 3% are not background noise.
Oil above $90 keeps inflation risk alive.
Nvidia/MediaTek is not just a chip deal. It is ecosystem control.
Custom silicon does not kill Nvidia if it plugs into Nvidia’s world.
September is a hedge-and-upgrade month, not a chase month.
Own scarce bottlenecks, durable workflows, and balance-sheet winners. Avoid blind AI beta.
The HEAT (Hedge, Edge, Asymmetry and Theme) Formula is designed to empower investors to spot opportunities, think independently, make smarter (often contrarian) moves, and build real wealth.
The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the Chief Executive Officer and Portfolio Manager for Tuttle Capital Management (TCM) and are subject to change without notice. The data and information provided is derived from sources deemed to be reliable but we cannot guarantee its accuracy. Investing in securities is subject to risk including the possible loss of principal. Trade notifications are for informational purposes only. TCM offers fully transparent ETFs and provides trade information for all actively managed ETFs. TCM's statements are not an endorsement of any company or a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security. Trade notification files are not provided until full trade execution at the end of a trading day. The time stamp of the email is the time of file upload and not necessarily the exact time of the trades. TCM is not a commodity trading advisor and content provided regarding commodity interests is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as a recommendation. Investment recommendations for any securities or product may be made only after a comprehensive suitability review of the investor’s financial situation.© 2026 Tuttle Capital Management, LLC (TCM). TCM is a SEC-Registered Investment Adviser. All rights reserved.